HARRISONBURG, Va. – From Dynasty Into Difficulty: McCurdy Leaves TA for Woebegone EMU

When JD McCurdy decided to move from the high school coaching ranks up to college, that was the headline from the July 1, 2003 Daily News Record. But McCurdy, who had already found immense success at Turner Ashby as the girls' softball coach, was ready to take that next step.

"It was the challenge," McCurdy explained. "We (TA) were dominating everything and I just wanted a new challenge. I always wanted to coach at the college level, and there wasn't many of those available in Virginia and I didn't want to move. So EMU was the opportunity."

And meet that challenge he has.

Now, 400+ wins, three ODAC Coach of the Year Honors, one NCAA Tournament appearance, three EMU Hall of Honor Inductees and countless All-ODAC award winners later, McCurdy is ready for another challenge…one that he's never quite faced before: retirement. McCurdy has announced that the 2026 season, his 23^rd at EMU, will be his last.

"It is time," he explained. "I've had other coaches tell me, 'you will know when it's time,' and I knew last year it was time for me to make a move and it's time to give the game up and move on and do something else. I appreciate and am grateful for the opportunity that I got here, and I'm very humbled with what happened. We did really well, but I knew it was time to move on and I feel really good with that."

When McCurdy applied for the position at EMU, he immediately became an attractive candidate to then Director of Athletics, Larry R. Martin, because of his track record as a head coach and his knowledge of the softball scene in the Shenandoah Valley.

"I hired him because of his success at the high school level," Martin said. "And because of  him knowing the area players for recruiting, because that's where most of our people got recruited from, was locally."

One of those aforementioned local players was Mariah Foltz '17. Foltz was a standout for the Broadway High School Gobblers softball team and made the decision to come play for McCurdy after her graduation in 2013. She also came back as an assistant coach with the Royals for the 2024 season. She explained that it was his drive to win, that drew her to EMU.

"I've always loved the way Coach McCurdy governs a team," Foltz said. "He coaches with authority and wants to win. I chose EMU because I wanted to continue to be a disciplined athlete, held to a high standard and pushed to succeed. I'm grateful to JD for pushing me to be stronger, resilient, and more accountable."

McCurdy's first season was in 2004 and, in just his first season, more than doubled the Royals win total from the previous year. The number of wins continued to climb each year until, in 2007 and 2008 McCurdy's stamp on the team was starting to be seen. In 2007, the Royals went 25-14, 10-8 in the ODAC and McCurdy was named the ODAC Co-Coach of the Year with Randolph Macon's Kevin Proffitt. He followed that up in 2008 with a record of 30-13, 13-5 in the ODAC, before falling in the ODAC semi-finals.

Over the next two years, EMU had sub .500 records in conference play, but made it to back-to-back ODAC Championship series. They fell to Lynchburg in 2009 but made it to the mountaintop in 2010, when they knocked off Virginia Wesleyan 5-1 to win EMU's second ODAC softball championship, their first since 1990, and earn a bid to the NCAA Tournament. McCurdy was rewarded for that season, as he was named, once again, the ODAC Coach of the Year.    

"JD had a knack for always having his team ready for the playoffs regardless of what the regular season was," said former Director of Athletics Dave King. "I didn't hear this necessarily, but it was sort of conveyed to me several ways that nobody really wanted to draw EMU in the first round of the ODAC tournament, and that one of his championships comes from having ranked eighth and come all the way through to the championship. And I never could figure out what it was about his coaching that did that. Again, I wasn't there at every practice and all that, but he had a knack. His teams played well in the ODAC tournament, and to me that says something."

Despite winning an ODAC championship, and not having another losing season until 2019, McCurdy explained that in his 23 years at the helm, he's had to adapt his coaching style to meet the needs of his players over the years.

"I felt like I could adjust to any situation with that," he said. "But kids 10 years ago were different than they are now, obviously. And I always felt that I could find a way, a button, that motivated them in some way. And even early on, I was hard. I was really a hard coach early on. I pushed my players, I pushed those kids but whatever happened within the team, I never let that bother the focus of what we wanted to do for the team and as a team."

Aislinn Bowen '16, said it was that pushing, and the drive, that made McCurdy the successful coach that he was.

"JD succeeds because he is consistent, detail driven, and genuinely invested in his players," she said. "He prepares harder than anyone, whether it is breaking down film, adjusting game strategies, or finding the right way to motivate his athletes. But what really sets him apart, is his ability to build relationships. He does not just coach players; he develops people. When you are playing for someone who truly invests in you, you naturally want to give everything you have. That culture of commitment and accountability is why his teams win."

While his teams haven't seen quite the same success in recent years as at the start of his career, his drive to develop players, and people, has never wavered.

"Coach McCurdy has been a consistent support in my life since an early age," said Grace Fravel '25. "He was committed to getting me to EMU, and I felt confident in my decision because I knew that he truly cared not only about my athletic career but also my academic journey and personal well-being. Not only was he a coach of mine, but he is also someone I knew I could always count on to help me navigate challenging times throughout my four years at EMU. His love for the game and his players is well known on and off the field. I feel extremely grateful to have had him as my coach, and I know that he has impacted many ladies' lives far beyond just my own.

But now, the time has come. After the season comes to an end, whenever that may be, McCurdy isn't planning on just riding off into the sunset…that's not who he is. He's just planning on looking for that next challenge, even if it's not on the softball field.

"I'm not quite sure what that next challenge is, but I can guarantee it'll be something," McCurdy explained. "I'm definitely going to be involved with my grandkids and their baseball. I'll spend time with my wife and do some traveling. But outside of that, it's up in the air."

And while he may not be at EMU anymore after this season, the impact he's made will continue to be felt long after a new coach is hired.

"JD's impact on EMU Softball is significant and lasting," said Carrie S. Bert '97, EMU's Director of Athletics. "Over the course of his career, he elevated the program, highlighted by an ODAC championship and more than 400 career wins. These milestones reflect both longevity and competitive excellence. He has been widely respected by local coaches, colleagues across the ODAC, and peers from all levels of the game for his knowledge, competitiveness, and long-standing commitment to softball. JD invested deeply in the sport and in this institution, and his commitment to recruiting and developing local student-athletes strengthened our connection to the surrounding community. We are grateful for the many years he dedicated to EMU and for the role he played in advancing our softball program during his tenure. JD has certainly earned a well-deserved retirement and we wish him all the best in this next chapter."

EMU will conduct a national search for McCurdy's replacement, beginning later this month. Any interested candidates can visit https://emu.edu/careers-at-emu/ for more information, once the position is posted.