Baseball

Brian Alderfer  (1983)
Doug Byler  (1985)
Daryl Lambert  (1992)
Maven Huffman  (1999)
Mike Gale  (2001)
Erik Kratz  (2002)

Men's Basketball

Miles Yoder  (1979)
Tim Crawford  (1981)
Larry Sheets  (1983)
Leonard Dow  (1986)
Gary Chupp  (1992)
Vaughn Troyer  (1993)
Carey Keyes  (1998)
Jason Sager  (2007)

Women's Basketball

Rachel Hershberger  (1979)
Dawn Marker McFarland  (1981)
Deana Moren Baker  (1986)
Ann Wenger Whipple  (1988)
Suzie French Welch  (1988)
Missy Hensley  (1992)
Emily Mullet Parker  (2003)
Bianca Ygarza (2014)

Men's Cross Country

Elton Horst  (1970)
Richy Bikko  (2011)

Women's Cross Country

Faith Eidse Kuhns  (1979)
Sarah Witmer Lehman  (1989)
Jeana Driver Golin  (1992)
Andrea Good Leaman  (2003)

Field Hockey

Melanie Gehret Baker  (1983)
Cheryl Bergey Derstine  (1985)
Linda Burkhart Myers  (1986)
Ann Wenger Whipple  (1988)
Tina Book  (1991)
Radella Todd Vrolijk  (1992)
Jeane Horning Hershey  (1994)
Jen Kooker Peifer  (1995)
Candance Sauder King  (1996)
Krista Ebersole Sensenig  (1997)
Kirsten (Brubaker) Fuhr  (1998)
Sherri Allebach Vass  (1999)
Laura Hess  (2000)
Sara Nissley  (2000)
Kristin Moyer Vasey  (2003)
Jonalyn Denlinger  (2005)
Kristina Landis Yoder  (2008)
Alyssa Derstine Landis  (2010)

Men's Soccer

Terry Koppenhaver  (1968)
Marvin Bunting  (1979)
Don Shank  (1980)
Kenny Shank  (1983)
Mike Martin  (1985)
Kurt Sauder  (1989)
Jeff Shank  (1994)
Clay Rosenberger  (1995)
Nate Derstine  (1996)
Mike Zook  (1999)
Ryan Brenneman  (1999)
Ben Yoder  (2008)

Women's Soccer

Ellie Lind Holsopple  (2003)
Joy Shaiebly Shelly  (2006)
Katie Lamm Spengler  (2008)

Softball

Dawn Gehman Lantz  (1982)
Anita Graber Miller  (1983)
Donna Wenger Widrick  (1990)
Tina Book  (1991)
Karla Alderfer Tierney  (1998)
Jamie "J-Fray" Runner (2008)
Miranda Terry (2008)
Lisa Simone Senger  (2012)
 

Men's Tennis

Glenn Deputy  (1981)

Women's Tennis

Amy Sauder  (2000)

Men's Track & Field

Jim Herr  (1979)
Kenny Layman  (1981)
Burrell Fisher  (1984)
Phil Landes  (1987)
Tim Cressman  (1991)
Adam Starks  (2003)
Jeremy Webster  (2007)
Luke Yoder (2008)
Michael Allen (2013)

Women's Track & Field

Charlene Peachey Brawley  (1983)
Ellie Bain Gathright  (1985)
Gretchen McCue Baugher  (1988)
Crystal Campbell  (1995)
Bessie Laws  (1999)
Laura Rosenberger  (2003)
Wendy Driver Rhodes  (2005)
Megan Mlinarchik  (2006)
Michelle Leaman Richards  (2010)
Andrea Good Leaman  (2003)

Men's Volleyball

Daryl Gross  (1993)
Mike Osinski  (1994)
Daryl Bert  (1997)
Eric Gehman  (1998)
Ben Yoder  (2008)

Women's Volleyball

June Davidhizar  (1978)
Lois Zook Arndt  (1979)
Debbie Dickerson Sanders  (1983)
Becky Derstine Esch  (1984)
Jill Basinger Mullet  (1984)
Jewel Lehman  (1987)
Charlene Yutzy Jacob  (1988)
Heidi King  (1989)
Ruth Steiner Friday  (1989)
Becky Miller Lyda  (1991)
Danielle Conser Siembida  (1998)
Gina Campbell Troyer (1993)

Wrestling

Glenn Metzler (1970)
Ross Hostetler (1979)

Coach/Administrator | () = Year Inducted

Eugene Hostetler (2002)
Miriam Mumaw (2002)
Sandra Brownscombe (2004)
Mike Downey (2022)

Royal Service Award | () = Year Inducted

Paul R. Yoder Sr. (2006)
Paul T. & Marjorie Guengerich (2008)
Dick & Helen Ours (2009)
Roland Landes (2024)

Teams | () = Year Inducted

1976 Mens Cross Country Team  (1976)
1980 Field Hockey Team (2012)
1995 Field Hockey Team (2008)
1998 Men's Soccer Team (2015)
2003-04 Women's Basketball Team (2023)
2009-10 Men's Basketball Team (2022)

Retired Jerseys 

Leonard Dow
Missy Hensley
Jeane Horning Hershey
Erik Kratz
Daryl Lambert
Jewel Lehman
Jeff Shank
Vaughn Troyer